Jump to Navigation

Cook County Jury Reaches 10 Million Dollar Verdict

Hinsdale grandmother injured in 2004 car accident

A Cook County jury reached a 10.121 Million Dollar verdict Friday evening in the case of Harvey vs. K-5 Construction. Attorneys Mark McNabola and Adria Mossing at Cogan & McNabola, P.C. tried the case to verdict before Judge James P. Flannery.

Seventy year-old Mary Harvey was driving to her daughter's Hinsdale home in 2004 when she was struck in an intersection by the defendant, James Fleck, an agent of K-5 Construction Company. How the intersection collision occurred was hotly debated. The defense contended that the driver had a green arrow and that Mary Harvey disobeyed the red light. Mrs Harvey testified that as she was going through the intersection on a green light, the defendant entered the intersection and turned left into her car. As a result of the accident, Mrs. Harvey suffered significant injuries including quadraparisis.

Mary Harvey is married to Dr. Gene Harvey, a retired family practice physician, and they have four grown children. Prior to this accident, she enjoyed an active lifestyle.

"Mr. Fleck's negligent driving took away Mary Harvey's ability to live her life to the fullest. She will never walk again due to his carelessness," said attorney Mark McNabola. "We are thankful that the jury believed our position 100%. This verdict completely validates Mary Harvey's actions that fateful day and will help her and her family emotionally and financially deal with this tragedy."

After seven days of testimony, the jury reached its decision in favor of Mary Harvey in less than two hours. The order of judgment was filed on Monday, October 30, 2006.

To speak to the attorneys or for more information on the case, call Maura Devine at 312 629 2900.

Our Results $475 Million
  • $14 Million
    For the family of a mother who died during child birth. Her newborn baby also suffered irreversible brain damage during the delivery at a Chicago hospital.
  • $11.4 Million
    Plaintiff was having a cervical fusion revision at Northwestern Memorial Hospital when his head dropped from neutral to 80 degrees.
  • $10.121 Million
    A Cook County jury returned the verdict in favor of a 72 year-old grandmother rendered wheelchair-dependent after a car vs. truck accident.
  • $10.1164 Million
    A 17 year-old girl was killed when she was struck by a vehicle which had previously collided with a Greyhound bus which was traveling too fast for conditions.
  • $ 7.875 Million
    A 64 year-old woman went to Swedish Covenant Hospital's ER with knee pain. She was treated and discharged. The hospital delayed the diagnosis and treatment of meningitis. The patient suffered a stroke and severe disability.
more results
How Can We Help? Referrals

We welcome clients who have been referred to our law firm by our peers. A large percentage of our firm's clients are referred to us by our attorney colleagues. We firmly believe other firms feel confident sending clients to our firm because of our effective and aggressive client advocacy.

Learn More
Contact Us

Cogan & McNabola, P.C.
Attorneys at Law

55 West Wacker Drive, 9th Floor
Chicago, IL 60601
Phone: 312-629-2900
Toll Free: 800-704-2900
Fax: 312-629-2916
Map and Directions

Privacy Policy | Legal Marketing® by FindLaw, a Thomson Reuters business.